1. Daubert Hearing Outcome: In August 2023, a pivotal Daubert hearing took place in the Paraquat Multidistrict Litigation (MDL), leading to a critical decision by Judge Rosentengel to exclude key testimony from Dr. Martin Wells, the Plaintiffs’ main expert on causation between Paraquat and Parkinson’s disease.

Dr. Wells had linked Paraquat exposure to Parkinson’s disease, but his methodology and findings were critically challenged, particularly around the definition of “occupational” exposure and the reliability of his meta-analysis.

2. Immediate Impact on Bellwether Cases

The judge’s ruling directly impacts four bellwether cases, effectively halting them due to the lack of established general causation without Dr. Wells’ testimony. This decision is a significant blow to the plaintiffs’ side, requiring a strategic regrouping.

3. Future Litigation Steps

Despite the setback, the litigation is not over. The court has ordered the selection of 16 new cases for limited fact discovery, with both sides—plaintiffs and defendants—choosing cases to proceed. This step is crucial as it will determine the future trajectory of the ongoing litigation.

4. Broader Implications and Next Steps

The broader Paraquat litigation continues in various state courts, including ongoing cases in Philadelphia. Plaintiffs’ attorneys are urged to strengthen their cases with robust expert evidence, aiming to establish a solid link between Paraquat and Parkinson’s disease for future trials.

This update underscores the complexity and challenges of mass tort litigation, highlighting the critical role of expert testimony in such cases.

Subscribe Now!

Get exclusive updates on the hottest trending torts by signing up for DemandLane newsletter!

By signing up you’re also agreeing to our Privacy Policy

By clicking the “Submit” Button, you consent to be called/texted at the number provided above by Demandlane. These calls/texts may be delivered via automated technology.